"Only dull people are brilliant at breakfast"
-Oscar Wilde
Brilliant at Breakfast title banner "The liberal soul shall be made fat, and he that watereth, shall be watered also himself."
-- Proverbs 11:25
"...you have a choice: be a fighting liberal or sit quietly. I know what I am, what are you?" -- Steve Gilliard, 1964 - 2007

"For straight up monster-stomping goodness, nothing makes smoke shoot out my ears like Brilliant@Breakfast" -- Tata

"...the best bleacher bum since Pete Axthelm" -- Randy K.

"I came here to chew bubblegum and kick ass. And I'm all out of bubblegum." -- "Rowdy" Roddy Piper (1954-2015), They Live
Saturday, March 26, 2005

Quote of the Day
Posted by Jill | 8:56 AM

...from a comment at John Cole's blog:

Is there no responsibility here? Could there not be some new Tim McVeigh out there, watching, weeping, plotting his revenge "for Terri"?
Bookmark and Share

OK, I take it back
Posted by Jill | 8:43 AM

I take back what I said about giving props to Jeb Bush for being a cooler head prevailing. Looks like he sent in the jackbooted thugs after all:

Hours after a judge ordered that Terri Schiavo was not to be removed from her hospice, a team of state agents were en route to seize her and have her feeding tube reinserted -- but they stopped short when local police told them they would enforce the judge's order, The Herald has learned.

Agents of the Florida Department of Law Enforcement told police in Pinellas Park, the small town where Schiavo lies at Hospice Woodside, on Thursday that they were on the way to take her to a hospital to resume her feeding.

For a brief period, local police, who have officers at the hospice to keep protesters out, prepared for what sources called ``a showdown.''

In the end, the squad from the FDLE and the Department of Children & Families backed down, apparently concerned about confronting local police outside the hospice.

''We told them that unless they had the judge with them when they came, they were not going to get in,'' said a source with the local police.

''The FDLE called to say they were en route to the scene,'' said an official with the city police who requested anonymity. ``When the sheriff's department and our department told them they could not enforce their order, they backed off.''

The incident,known only to a few and related to The Herald by three different sources involved in Thursday's events, underscores the intense emotion and murky legal terrain that the Schiavo case has created. It also shows that agencies answering directly to Gov. Jeb Bush had planned to use a wrinkle in Florida law that would have allowed them to legally get around the judge's order. The exception in the law allows public agencies to freeze a judge's order whenever an agency appeals it.


Swell. Now we have state law enforcement damn near getting into an altercation with local law enforcement.

Regardless of where you stand on the fate of Terri Schiavo herself (and frankly, I wish she would wake up right now and tell us what she thinks), this is madness. Law-and-order Republicans are no longer talking about the rule of law; no longer talking about how "the system worked", no longer having any respect for the justice system, even when the decisions are coming down from conservative judges. Instead, they're advocating mob rule.

And these are the people who made their name on respecting less government and the rule of law?
Bookmark and Share

The beast is out of control now
Posted by Jill | 6:54 AM

One of our commenters has posted some interesting and thought-provoking stuff about the kinds of capacities some brain-injured people may have that are not readily apparent. If we're going to be talking about whether Terri Schiavo is or is not in a persistent vegetative state, and/or what kind of cognitive abilities she may or may not have, THAT's the field on which this discussion should take place.

The people who are claiming now that Schiavo is alert and talking are NOT doing this discussion any favors. The public has been bombarded with four-year-old video of someone whose eyes are open, and who appears to be smiling (though photos I've seen taken from the video indicate that much of that expression depends on the camera angle; at other angles it looks like a rictus of terror). To the lay person, open eyes = alertness. To be awake but not able to think is as incomprehensible as death itself. We try to put ourselves in Terri Schiavo's place, and we really can't.

Comedian Wanda Sykes has a hilarious bit about how women are always thinking. "Have you ever once had a moment of silence in your head?" I can't speak for anyone else, but for me the answer is a resounding "NO!" Those who know me know that I rarely stop talking. What they don't know is that this patter goes on even when I'm not. To me, the idea of having that silence in my head is beyond comprehension. Does Terri Schiavo have that silence in her head? Or is the patter still going on, but trapped?

It's clear that there's much we still don't know about how the human brain works. If anything good comes out of this whole mess, it'll be because more people will think about what they do and do not want done for themselves in a similar situation, and will put those wishes in writing. And it just might spur additional interest (and hopefully funding) for brain research.

Those are the potential positives. The negative is that the fundamentalist faux-Christian beast that's been rattling the bars of its cage since the mid-1970's has finally broken out of its so-called prison. It's hungry, it's angry, and it's out to destroy everything in its path if it has to in order to feed itself.

Steve Gilliard:

That line from Red October is running through my head again:"This business will get out of control. It will get out of control and we will be lucky to live through it."

Why? Because the Republicans are still counting fundie votes. They think they can control this, that nothing will happen and the base will be excited. But most of the base is revolted. They are horrifed at the sanctimony and the increasing rhetoric from people who should know better. Ignore judges? Kidnap a dying woman? Are they kidding?

Why is this happening? Because they thought it would be a gimmie. That the only people who would care is the radical right and their foot soldiers. They could get their way and trap the Dems in the process. But now, the Dems stepped out of the way and let the GOP take every bit of heat for this. You have the spectacle of Randall Terry, has-been, making demands on Jeb Bush, who meekly says "I can't go beyond my powers."

Bush and Bush seem to be puppets of the fringe elements, a group who would let their kids get arrested, which horrifies most people. All that political capital has been squandered, as Jim Wolcott said, on a Sunday flight from Crawford.

But Bush has never spread political risk. He has always heaped it on and expected to be rewarded in the end. There has never been a downside for this. But there is now. If Judge Greer or Michael Schiavo is harmed in any way, that turd is going to land right on the doors of the White House and Congress. They unleashed this madness and the idea that they could escape it is unlikely.
Bookmark and Share
Friday, March 25, 2005

Wacko Armageddon is Imminent
Posted by Jill | 7:16 PM

Sorry, no cat blogging today...my digital camera is lost under a pile of obsolete computer books and other effluvia after damn near needing a backhoe to get all the junk out of our home office so we can paint it a lovely, calming, and soothing shade of taupe. And somehow, "Friday All Hell Has Broken Loose In My House Blogging" just doesn't quite have the same "cute factor."

But speaking of all Hell breaking loose, the wackjobs in Florida are getting ready for some Extreme Nastiness when, as is expected since her parents' legal options are running out, Terri Schiavo at last is freed from the body and the people that betrayed her and depending on your belief, goes home to Jesus, goes to her eternal rest, or leaves this incarnation behind and either gets ready for the next one or moves on to eternal unity with the universe.

In true "culture of life" fashion, the death-centered "pro-life" movement is gearing up for a little of the old ultra-violence. The Kansas City Star reports:

Some pro-life activists are making ugly threats, making up "Wanted" posters for lawmakers and handing out the home addresses of judges who rejected legal appeals to keep Schiavo alive.

"I am afraid," said state Sen. Frederica Wilson, D-Miami, who has received numerous death threats by phone and mail because she voted against a measure to reinsert Schiavo's feeding tube. "We're talking about the sanctity of life, and (they're) threatening my life."

The nine Republican lawmakers who voted against the measure showed up on anonymous "Wanted" posters that appeared in the state capitol in Tallahassee. State Sen. Nancy Argenziano said one of the "un-Christian" voice mails she's received wished stomach cancer on her.

Guards have been posted outside the politicians' offices.

Police won't discuss their security measures, but Michael Schiavo and Judge George Greer, who has consistently upheld Schiavo's requests to end his wife's life, are under around-the-clock protection and staying out of sight. Both have been the targets of a flood of fury, branding them corrupt and abusive murderers who are flouting God.

"Various law enforcement agencies are aware of the emotions in this case and have taken appropriate actions," said Wayne Shelor, spokesman for the police in Clearwater, Fla., where Michael Schiavo lives.

Popular right-wing Web sites have had to post prominent warnings against threats of violence on their discussion boards after calls for the armed "liberation" of Terri Schiavo from her hospice and comments suggesting that if her husband were taken out of the picture, guardianship would revert to her parents, who want to keep her alive.

People on Schiavo's street in Clearwater have received anonymous postcards saying: "Your neighbor Michael Schiavo is trying to murder his wife."


In addition, it seems that over a dozen moronic lunatics are being arrested while trying to bring cups of water to Terri Schiavo at her Pinellas Park hospice (as if she were running a marathon), including two 13-year-old girls and a 10-year-old boy. (This is a typical lunatic right gambit -- put the children out there as human shields. Stephen King sure had the character of Gregg Stillson just right in The Dead Zone, didn't he?

And in the "Killing for Christ" department, we have the Illinois man who was arrested after trying to steal a gun so he could "rescue Terri Schiavo."

You know, I'm not going to give Jeb Bush credit for much. I think he's every bit as vile, venal, greedy, and corrupt as everyone else in his family. But I'll give him credit for not acquiescing to the insane calls to send troops to Pinellas Park to kidnap what's left of Terri Schiavo. Whether it's simply because he's smart enough to know that a gunfight between guys in military uniforms and protesters will just about mean the death knell of his obvious, if still denied, 2008 Presidential campaign, or because he really believes in following the rule of law, at least so far, his cooler head has prevailed.

But you know what? I hate this. I hate this whole thing. I hate it as much as I'm participating in it. I hate how this story has knocked everything else off of the news wires. I hate that this tragic woman has turned into a political football to be kicked around by the phony Christians, the crazies, and corrupt politicians. I hate that I've lost sympathy for a family because they've allowed themselves to be manipulated by people like Randall Terry. I hate that I just want this to be over. I hate that tens of thousands of families who have been through this are having to relive their nightmare. I hate what my country has turned into this week. America had a nervous breakdown after 9/11/01, and this week we've had another one.
Bookmark and Share

Friday morning roundup
Posted by Jill | 7:55 AM

I'm spending the day at home today, in a cozy little ménage à trois with Mr. Brilliant and Benjamin Moore.

So here's some of what you ought to check out today.


  • I hate to link to Jeff Jarvis; his ego is quite large enough already, thank you very much (not that links from little ol' me mean a heck of a lot), but he has a decent compilation of excerpts from conservative bloggers about a possible "GOP Meltdown" over the Schiavo case.

  • Lost in the screeching that is Terrimania is the fact that C-Plus Caligula has been utterly silent on the deaths of ten Native Americans, one of them the shooter, in the Minnesota school shooting earlier this week:
    "The fact that Bush preempted his vacation to say something about Ms. Schiavo and here you have 10 native people gunned down and he can't take time to speak is very telling," said David Wilkins, interim chairman of the Department of American Indian Studies at the University of Minnesota and a member of the North Carolina-based Lumbee tribe.

    Why people continue to be surprised that Bush's "culture of life" only applies to white Christians is beyond me.

  • Media Matters reminds us of the background of Schindler family spokesnut Randall Terry. Perhaps it's unfair, but the Schindlers lost much of the sympathy I had for them when they made the Faustian bargain to have this domestic terrorist speak for them.

  • John Gorenfeld, best known for bringing us the news of the coronation of the Rev. Sun Myung Moon as the Messiah in the halls of Congress last year, now tells us of the child abuser who is now the U.S. Ambassador to Italy.

  • Bob Herbert has a nice rundown of some of the consequences of the Bush Budget -- child-care assistance for over 300,000 of the poor ended by 2009, cuts in food assistance for pregnant women, infants and children, cuts in funding for H.I.V. and AIDS treatment of over half a billion dollars over five years (whatever happened to that $15 billion, anyway?). And over a half-billion in tax cuts for the wealthy. More proof that that the Fundie right cares about life before birth, and preventing white Christians from going home to Jesus (maybe it's to ensure a good, mediagenic turnout for the Rapture?).

  • I can't seem to stop looking at articles about Vespas....which is pretty strange because I am scared to death of motorcycles. But I work 10 miles from work, it's all roads of 40mph or less, and well, a Vespa gets 65mpg. We may all be riding Vespas soon, if Kenneth Deffeyes is correct.

  • The Schiavo case is resulting in some pretty interesting behavior on the part of talking heads. I don't usually watch the Abrams Report, which comes on MSNBC after Olbermann's show, but it's been fascinating to watch this week, as Dan Abrams' head has come very close to exploding several times this week as he's interviewed some of the delusional wingnuts who insist that Terri Schiavo is just days away from full cognition. Today, even the usually subdued David Shuster pulls the curtain away from the Congressional grandstanding to show the law that Bill Frist and Tom DeLay have been touting for the toothless exercise in political cynicism that it is:
    Based on what Schiavo's parents have been saying this week, it appears the legislation's fine print was never shared with them by Bill Frist or anybody else for that matter. Early Monday morning, after President Bush signed the Schiavo bill, Bob Schindler was positively beaming in front of the television cameras. He said he walked into his daughter's hospice room and told her, "We had to wake the President up to save your life."

    Did Bill Frist and Tom Delay ever call the Schindler family and say, "not so fast?" Apparently not. In their latest court filing, the Schinder family still clings to the misleading notion offered by lawmakers last weekend that their bill required Schiavo's feeding tube to be immediately reinserted. Quote, "If Congress meant to give the federal courts the power to let her die..." says the Schindler's filing, then passing the law "would be little more than a cruel hoax." Read it again... The Schindlers argue: "If Congress meant to give the federal courts the power..." The fact is, that's exactly what Congress did. And a "cruel hoax" on Terry Schiavo's family is exactly the right description.
Bookmark and Share

Bill Frist, a hypocrite? I'm SHOCKED, I tell ya!
Posted by Jill | 7:21 AM

Where is the outrage? Think of the children!

Sen. Bill Frist (R-Quack) has decided, based on watching a video, that Terri Schiavo is just about ready to get up and join the company of Riverdance, then win the National Spelling Bee, and that evil liberals are trying to kill her.

Funny how DOCTOR Frist wasn't as hopeful when it came to the case of someone who was incapacitated, but still had a cerebral cortex. This tidbit comes to us courtesy of DC Inside Scoop.

Bill Frist now:

"Remember, Terri is alive. She is not in a coma," Frist said Sunday. "Although there are a range of opinions, neurologists who have examined her insist today that she is not in a persistent vegetative state. She breathes on her own - like you and me. She is not on a respirator. She is not on life support of any type. She does not have a terminal condition." [The Tennessean, 3/22/05]


Bill Frist then:

Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist attacked Sen. John Edwards for saying that stem cell research would enable people like Christopher Reeve to “get up out of that wheelchair and walk again.”

Frist responded on a conference call with reporters arranged by the Bush-Cheney campaign: "I find it opportunistic to use the death of someone like Christopher Reeve -- I think it is shameful -- in order to mislead the American people… We should be offering people hope, but neither physicians, scientists, public servants or trial lawyers like John Edwards should be offering hype.

"It is cruel to people who have disabilities and chronic diseases, and, on top of that, it's dishonest. It's giving false hope to people, and I can tell you as a physician who's treated scores of thousands of patients that you don't give them false hope." [CNN.com, 10/12/04]


Am I implying that the pious cat-killer, DOCTOR Frist, is nothing more than another cynical politician, making a calculation to appeal to the wackiest sliver of the Jesusland base for his 2008 presidential run? Nope. I'm not implying anything. I'm screaming it to the skies.

Isn't it just possible that the kind of stem cell research that Bill Frist felt might give people like Christopher Reeve "false hope" just might eventually help people like Terri Schiavo?
Bookmark and Share
Thursday, March 24, 2005

This week in a nutshell
Posted by Jill | 11:21 AM

...at Get your War On.

(WARNING: THE ABOVE LINK MAY BE HAZARDOUS TO YOUR KEYBOARD. BE SURE TO COVER ALL COFFEE CUPS AND OTHER BEVERAGES BEFORE READING.)

(via Running Scared)
Bookmark and Share

But enough about me, how do you like my dress?
Posted by Jill | 7:36 AM

I tell you, ladies and gentlemen, one thing God has brought to us is Terri Schiavo to elevate the visibility of what's going on in America. That Americans would be so barbaric as to pull a feeding tube out of a person that is lucid and starve them to death for two weeks. I mean, in America that's going to happen if we don't win this fight.

And so it's bigger than any one of us, and we have to do everything that is in our power to save Terri Schiavo and anybody else that may be in this kind of position, and let me just finish with this:

This is exactly the kind of issue that's going on in America, that attacks against the conservative moment, against me and against many others. -- Tom DeLay, March 18, 2005


Narcissistic Personality Disorder: an all-pervasive pattern of grandiosity (in fantasy or behavior), need for admiration or adulation and lack of empathy, usually beginning by early adulthood and present in various contexts. -- Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, fourth edition, Text Revision (DSM-IV-TR), 2000
Bookmark and Share

Quote of the Day
Posted by Jill | 7:35 AM

MoDo:

The president, who couldn't be dragged outdoors to talk about the more than a hundred thousand people who died in the horrific tsunami, was willing to be dragged out of bed to sign a bill about one woman his base had fixated on.
Bookmark and Share

Meanwhile, elsewhere in the Republican "Culture of Life"
Posted by Jill | 7:30 AM

Tom Friedman, the New York Times foremost apologist for Bush's Iraq war, and fellow denizen of the Bush Manufactured Reality Bubble, reminds us today of how highly selective the Republican "culture of life" is:

You have to stop and think about this: We killed 26 of our prisoners of war. In 18 cases, people have been recommended for prosecution or action by their supervising agencies, and eight other cases are still under investigation. That is simply appalling. Only one of the deaths occurred at the Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq, reported Jehl and Schmitt - "showing how broadly the most violent abuses extended beyond those prison walls and contradicting early impressions that the wrongdoing was confined to a handful of members of the military police on the prison's night shift."

Yes, I know war is hell and ugliness abounds in every corner. I also understand that in places like Iraq and Afghanistan, we are up against a vicious enemy, which, if it had the power, would do great harm to our country. You do not deal with such people with kid gloves. But killing prisoners of war, presumably in the act of torture, is an inexcusable outrage. The fact that Congress has just shrugged this off, and no senior official or officer has been fired, is a travesty. This administration is for "ownership" of everything except responsibility.
Bookmark and Share

All Terri Schiavo, All the Time
Posted by Jill | 7:01 AM
WaPo has a must-read interview with Dr. Jay Wolfson, author of the 2003 report at Abstract Appeal on the Schiavo case.

Meanwhile, it looks like the Republicans, led by certain 2008 Presidential candidates Jeb Bush, Rick Santorum, and Bill Frist, may have overplayed their hand here. A CBS News poll reveals that four of five people polled opposed federal intervention, with levels of disapproval among key groups supporting the GOP almost that high.

C-Plus Caligula's approval has taken a hit too -- down to 43%. (Watch for more terror warnings, maybe even another Osama Bin Laden tape, coming soon to a television near you.)

Most Americans say they feel sympathy for family members on both sides of the dispute over the 41-year-old Schiavo, according to a CNN-USA Today-Gallup poll.

More than eight in 10 in that poll said they feel sympathy for Bob and Mary Schindler, parents of Schiavo, who want to keep her alive. And seven in 10 said they're sympathetic for Michael Schiavo, the husband of Schiavo who says she should be allowed to die.


I'm gratified that most Americans, even those identifying themselves as evangelical Christians, aren't being taken in by the self-serving carny sideshow in Washington and in the governor's mansion in Florida. That a nearly-equal percentage are able to sympathize with both parties in this case is an indication that when pressed, Americans are still able to hold two ideas in their heads at the same time, and are still able to recognize extreme cynicism when they see it.

So what was the last straw? Was it Tom DeLay saying that Terri Schiavo was God's gift to him? Was it Bill Frist, a physician, doing armchair diagnosis by videotape? Was it Jeb Bush, who is cutting the very same Medicaid payments in his state that are keeping Terri Schiavo alive? Or is it simply that too many Americans either have been, or will be, in this situation at some point in their lives, and they do NOT want politicians intervening in their families?

The kind of vocal, lunatic fringe to whom Republicans are playing can't be any more than, oh, say, fifteen percent of the population. In an effort to placate this fringe that demands ideological purity, Republicans are turning off the very swing voters they regarded as so important just a few months ago.

Amazingly, most Americans, despite the best efforts of the screaming media to convince them otherwise, are still willing to countenance the idea that there are no bad guys in this family, that both sides can be intelligent people of goodwill who honestly believe they are doing the right thing for a terribly damaged family member, but who disagree about what that is.
Bookmark and Share
Wednesday, March 23, 2005

Quote of the Day
Posted by Jill | 6:29 PM

....from DavidNYC at Kos, in response to Jeb Bush's latest attempt to wrest custody of Terri Schiavo away from Michael Schiavo because a 'renowned neurologist' who visited with Ms. Schiavo for an hour recently does not agree that she is in a persistent vegetative state"

If only these guys demanded such certainty in death penalty cases, I might almost believe them.
Bookmark and Share

A stroll down memory lane
Posted by Jill | 8:19 AM

Now that the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals has refused to order the re-insertion of Terri Schiavo's feeding tube, there's very little doubt in my mind that this case will continue on its relentless march to the Supreme Court.

When it does, it will be interesting to see what Antonin Scalia does with it. Keep an eye on this, folks, for here's what he said in a similar case, Cruzan by Cruzan v. Director, Missouri Department of Health, in 1990 (emphases mine):

While I agree with the Court's analysis today, and therefore join in its opinion, I would have preferred that we announce, clearly and promptly, that the federal courts have no business in this field; that American law has always accorded the State the power to prevent, by force if necessary, suicide -- including suicide by refusing to take appropriate measures necessary to preserve one's life; that the point at which life becomes "worthless," and the point at which the means necessary to preserve it become "extraordinary" or "inappropriate," are neither set forth in the Constitution nor known to the nine Justices of this Court any better than they are known to nine people picked at random from the Kansas City telephone directory; and hence, that even when it is demonstrated by clear and convincing evidence that a patient no longer wishes certain measures to be taken to preserve her life, it is up to the citizens of Missouri to decide, through their elected representatives, whether that wish will be honored. It is quite impossible (because the Constitution says nothing about the matter) that those citizens will decide upon a line less lawful than the one we would choose; and it is unlikely (because we know no more about "life-and-death" than they do) that they will decide upon a line less reasonable.
Bookmark and Share

And MORE idiocy from so-called Christians
Posted by Jill | 7:10 AM

Oh, brother.

This one takes a meandering path through Blogistan, ending up at Poetic Leanings:

Terri Schiavo can continue to live even though her feeding tube has been removed. Yes! She Can! Believe it! We can all participate in sustaining her physical life.

On Friday, March 18, 2005, at 1:00 pm. Michael Schiavo orders the removal of his wife Terri’s feeding tube in compliance of the court order of Judge Greer. The feeding tube is removed.

During the course of Holy Week the secular world watches as starvation takes its toll on Terri Schiavo. Few, if any, will make any connection between John Paul II’s breathing tube and Terri’s feeding tube.

Religious people of all persuasions fast and pray, and do all manner of penance and sacrifice pleading with Almighty God for Terri and for the world.

At 3:00 pm on March 25, Good Friday, the entire world falls victim to absolute, total, complete darkness.

Panic and fear grip the masses the world over.

Only John Paul II and Terri know what’s going on.

The pope made a curious comment recently about the “days of darkness” very soon to be upon us which he did not go on to explain.

Mary explained it to Terri in a vision when the International Pilgrim Virgin Statue of Our Lady of Fatima visited Clearwater.

As Easter arrives and Jesus rises from the tomb, Terri Schiavo rises from her hospice bed completely restored to health. The world witnesses a miracle.

Introspection become the order of the day.

A new Springtime in the Church begins.


Wow! So it's really Terri Schiavo who's the Second Coming of Jesus? Somebody had better tell George W. Bush. He'll be SO disappointed. All this time he thought HE was.
Bookmark and Share

More idiocy from so-called Christians
Posted by Jill | 7:00 AM

This one's via Americablog from our good friends and lunatics over at Agape Press:

...A Jewish author says it isn't anti-Semitic to note that Jesus was handed over to the Romans for crucifixion by Jewish leaders. In his new book -- Why the Jews Rejected Jesus: The Turning Point in Western History -- David Klinghoffer quotes the Talmud, which says that "on the eve of Passover they hung Yeshu (Jesus)" on charges that he "performed magic, enticed and led astray Israel." The Talmud also claims that Mary conceived Jesus in adultery and that Jesus suffers eternal punishment. But Klinghoffer says fear of Christian persecution caused Jews centuries ago to relegate such materials to footnotes in tiny type or delete them altogether. Anyway, he says, the real dispute between Jews and Christians concerns whether Jesus was Israel's messiah and the Son of God who properly exercised authority to reinterpret divine law.


Who knew the Talmud was written in English?

Thanks to the Miracle that is Google, 30 seconds of searching yielded this, this, and this. Scholars have pondered this question for years, and as many scholars have come to the conclusion that the "Yeshu" and "Miriam" referred to in the Talmud were NOT the Jesus and Mary of the New Testament. In reality, "Yeshu" and "Miriam" were common names at the time. This is like saying that every 30-ish man named "Joshua" is a literal descendent of Jesus (though every time I see Josh Lucas in a movie, well, it makes me wonder...).

I will never understand why Jews are allowing themselves to be cast as useful idiots by the Bible-thumping right.
Bookmark and Share
Tuesday, March 22, 2005

Making sense of it all
Posted by Jill | 10:13 PM

I guess there's just no getting around being sucked into the vortex surrounding Terri Schiavo. This story is inevitably compelling, in a horrible sort of way, because ultimately each of us tries to put ourselves into her shoes, and we're unable to do so.

What we are, how we think, THAT we think, what we see, hear, and experience, is so much the result of electrical impulses in our brains. Most of us have no understanding of how it all works. We wake in the morning, we eat, take care of ourselves, go to work, process inputs, produce outputs, go to sleep, dream -- and never think much about it.

After weeks of being bombarded with the haunting face of someone who is either trapped in a body that doesn't work, or who IS now just a body that functions as a body but nothing else, it kind of forces us to confront just what it is that makes us human.

It's so easy to just assume that there's some great white Alpha male with a beard in the sky who molds us out of clay and micromanages each of our lives. This sort of all-powerful parental authority figure is a concept that at least makes sense to us. But looking at the vacant stare of Terri Schaivo can't help but call that notion into question. After all, what kind of micromanager would be cruel enough to do this to someone? And why on earth would we worship something that cruel?

On the other hand, the idea that something as simple as loss of circulation can cause all that makes us human to burn out that quickly, that easily, well, it makes us all kind of insignificant, doesn't it?

Let's face it, folks: Terri Schiavo makes us uncomfortable. I don't care if you're Tom DeLay or me or Michael Schiavo or anyone: There's something weird about this kind of "present absence", and understanding it is like trying to understand death. Either you put it into some kind of model you can understand, like "heaven" -- a Club Med for the righteous -- or you put it out of your mind because it's Just Too Big.

But for the many people trying to sort out what's happening here in a futile effort to get to "the truth", whatever that may be, there's no better resource than Abstract Appeal. Matt Conigliaro has a wealth of material, including a surprising report (Adobe Acrobat required) by a Guardian Ad Litem for Terri Schiavo that debunks the notion that the last fifteen years have been a nonstop battle between Michael Schiavo and his in-laws. This report, which details the personal, medical, and legal history of the case, is pretty astonishing stuff, and definitely worth reading.

I've tried not to get into too many discussions on this case, mostly because each of us comes to this story with our own baggage. I can relate to this woman's battle with her weight, and with the cruel irony that she only reached her desired weight after becoming bulimic -- and paid for it with her very selfhood. Another person might relate to the disability aspect. Someone else may be affected by what may seem to be a form of abandonment, in which her husband has moved on to create a new life. But the fact of the matter is that over 99% of us do not know these people, and do not know this family.

Michael Schiavo may have been a lousy husband. Maybe he picked on his wife about her weight. Maybe what started out as a simple desire to please her husband turned into an obsession on Terri Schiavo's part, one with a terribly high price. Maybe he HAS lost patience with her parents' refusal to let go. Maybe he should have waited to produce children with someone else until the situation was resolved. Maybe, maybe, maybe. Maybe the Schindlers have sold their souls to a bunch of cynical snake-oil salesmen who care not a fig for their pain, but only for political gain for themselves.

There's only one thing I DO know, and that's the one thing any of us know: Not one of us would trade places with any of these people for a minute. Let's not lose track of the fact that this is a nightmare for this family...and that there are many other families in this country dealing with similar nightmares every day. I'm sure that the Schindlers love their daughter and they believe they're doing the right thing by fighting for what they see to be life and hope. I'm also sure that Michael Schiavo similarly believes he's fighting for what his wife would want if she were able to communicate it. It's not for us to judge any of them until and unless we take a walk in their shoes.
Bookmark and Share

...which is always involved in infighting with the White House Department of Bullshit:

The reason [the president] supports the death penalty is because it helps -- he believes that it helps save lives, and he's stated that view clearly and consistently over a number of years."


I wonder how long Scott McClellan has to rehearse to be able to say stuff like that with a straight face?
Bookmark and Share

Next Stop: Supreme Court
Posted by Jill | 7:18 AM

And for those of you who think that the Supreme Court wasn't an issue in this past election, take heed now.

A federal judge here today refused to order the reinsertion of a feeding tube for the brain-damaged Terri Schiavo, despite the intervention of Congress and President Bush in the case, The Associated Press reported.

Judge Dames D. Whittemore of Federal District Court said the 41-year-old woman's parents had not established a "substantial likelihood of success" at trial on the merits of their arguments, the agency said.

The tube was disconnected on Friday on the orders of a state judge.

After two hours of tense and often emotional arguments on Monday, Judge Whittemore refused to rule immediately on whether to restore nutrition to Ms. Schiavo, whose husband won a state court's permission to remove her feeding tube. Judge Whittemore also expressed doubts about whether a federal review could change the ultimate outcome and seemed skeptical of the parents' contention that the state courts had violated Ms. Schiavo's right to due process.


Now, this isn't the end of Judge Whittemore's review, and it's starting to look increasingly like Terri Schiavo may die during his deliberations, making the whole point moot except as a precedent, which may be the point. (I'll let the legal scholars among us weigh in in the comments.)

But you can bet your life (no pun intended, though if the shoe fits...) that whether Terri Schiavo lives or dies, this case is going to the Supreme Court.

Patrick Gudridge, a law professor at the University of Miami is quoted in a Christian Science Monitor op-ed piece as saying, "It would appear to be the kind of legislative grandstanding that Chief Justice Rehnquist, if he were up to speed and in good health, would swat away in an instant."

Chief Justice Scalia, however, would adjudicate far differently, as would most, if not all, of the extremists George W. Bush has waiting in line for Supreme Court vacancies.
Bookmark and Share

Quote of the Day
Posted by Jill | 7:14 AM

This is Holy Week, this is when the Catholic community is saying, "We understand that life is not an absolute good and death is not an absolute defeat." The whole story of Easter is about the triumph of eternal life over death. Catholics have never believed that biological life is an end in and of itself. We've been created as a gift from God and are ultimately destined to go back to God. And we've been destined in this life to be involved in relationships. And when the capacity for that life is exhausted, there is no obligation to make officious efforts to sustain it. -- Rev. John Paris, Catholic theologian and Walsh Professor of Bioethics at Boston College, in an interview with Salon, 3/22/2005


Bookmark and Share

There now, that wasn't so hard, was it?
Posted by Jill | 7:06 AM

Into this sea of shit that is the Terri Schiavo case comes a small bright spot this morning. Americablog brings us news that the head of the Roman Catholic Diocese of San Diego, Bishop Robert Brom, has apologized to the family of a gay man to whom he had refused a Catholic burial:

The head of the Roman Catholic Diocese of San Diego apologized Monday to the family of gay nightclub owner John McCusker, less than a week after decreeing that McCusker couldn't have a Catholic burial because of his "business activities," according to a statement released by McCusker's family.

In a stunning twist to a controversy that has created an uproar in the San Diego gay and Catholic communities, Bishop Robert Brom also promised to preside at a mass in memory of McCusker at The Immaculata Catholic church on the campus of the University of San Diego.

[snip]

In a statement released by McCusker's family Monday night, the bishop was quoted as saying: "I deeply regret that denying a Catholic funeral for John McCusker at the Immaculata has resulted in his unjust condemnation, and I apologize to the family for the anguish this has caused them."


Now the apology was still issued in the passive voice (I'd be more impressed if it read, "I deeply regret that my decision to deny a Catholic funeral for John McCusker at the Immaculata has resulted in his unjust condemnation, and I apologize to the family for the anguish I caused them"), but it's still an apology, and John McCusker will not only receive a Catholic funeral, but Brom himself will preside over the mass.

Two little words: "I apologize". So simple, and yet they mean one heck of a lot to the gay community of San Diego today.

George W. Bush take note.
Bookmark and Share
Monday, March 21, 2005

More wondering....
Posted by Jill | 4:17 PM

Jeff at Red Hair Black Leather wonders:

Where were all these people when Lauren Rainey was in dire straits not so long ago?
Bookmark and Share

Star Wars III: "Titanic in Space"
Posted by Jill | 3:25 PM

[Posted because man cannot live by Republican grandstanding alone]

So sayeth George Lucas, which ought to save a whole lot of people about ten bucks a pop.

Now, I'm not knocking Titanic. It's easy to look back now and wonder what all the fuss was about, now that we've all seen it a dozen times and even those of us who let ourselves get carried away by the spectacle and the meticulous re-creation of a White Star ship and the costumes and the archetype of "Woman Triumphant" and even the cornography of its central romance (and yes, I plead guilty; how guilty most of you have no idea).

I'm not knocking Star Wars either, though I never found the original three movies to be all that compelling, not being a sci-fi fan. But George Lucas hasn't made a decent film since his ego swelled up to the size of Tom DeLay's balls in the aftermath of being mentioned by Joseph Campbell. The first two films in the latter Star Wars oeuvre were absolutely insufferable. Not every director can manage the seemingly impossible feat of sucking all the charm and charisma out of Ewan McGregor, all the testosterone out of Liam Neeson, and make Natalie Portman seem about as good an actress as Paris Hilton. Anyone who saw Shattered Glass knows that even poor, hapless Hayden Christensen isn't as bad as Lucas has made him seem. And as far as I'm concerned, once they killed off Terence Stamp early on in The Fandom Menace, it was all over.

Sure, the special effects are reliable, but effects do not compensate for lack of a coherent story PLUS an awful script PLUS lugubrious performances. You already know that Anakin Skywalker becomes Darth Vader; what Lucas has to do, and so far has failed miserably, is make you want to know why. And frankly, my dear, I really don't give a shit. I mean, it's been pretty clear that Ben Hawkins and Brother Justin Crowe are headed for a showdown in Carnívale, but it's been one hell of an interesting ride getting Daniel Knauf's crew of motley carnies to the revival tents at New Caanan. And you knew that the ship was going to sink in Titanic, but that didn't stop a whole bunch of people from suspending disbelief long enough to hope that Leonardo DiCaprio would be that most rarified of creatures: the surviving steerage male.

So the idea of having this sort of "good vs. evil" showdown leavened by more of the awful crap we saw as Christensen and Portman cavorted in the meadow in Attack of the Clones, all in the ham-handed fists of the self-important Mr. Lucas, and Revenge of the Sith is starting to sound more like a turkey gobbler by the day.

We now return you to our nonstop coverage of Republican Selective Grandstanding.
Bookmark and Share

The Republican "Culture of Life": Second in a Series
Posted by Jill | 1:32 PM
An intermittent series designed to call attention to the Republican "Culture of Life" that they want publicized as a result of their superhuman efforts to "save Terri".


The military has announced today that nother U.S. serviceman has been killed in action in Iraq's western Al Anbar province.

Meanwhile, 10,000 a month continue to die in Darfur. Congress has done nothing. Neither has the President.
Bookmark and Share

Lie down, dogs, fleas, etc.
Posted by Jill | 1:11 PM

World O'Crap has some lovely information about Randall Terry, the man who has taken advantage of Terri Schiavo's parents' grief to become their "spokesman". It's worth checking out, especially on the off chance you're inclined to write a check.

I especially like the part where he calls Michael Schiavo a "monster", this from a guy who left his own wife for someone else. Pot, kettle, etc.
Bookmark and Share

A penny for YOUR thoughts
Posted by Jill | 8:16 AM

In view of Congress and the President overriding Florida state law and the Florida courts in the Terri Schiavo case, does anyone still actually believe that if Roe v. Wade is overturned, the First/DeLay/Bush Axis of Evil will allow abortion to remain a state issue?

If the case of one hopelessly brain-damaged woman in Florida warrants Federal intervention, does anyone believe they won't do the same with abortion?

Just wondering...
Bookmark and Share

The Republican Culture of Life: First in a Series
Posted by Jill | 8:09 AM

I thought it might be interesting to post examples of how the policies of the Bush/Frist/DeLay Axis of Evil create a "culture of life", since they're so obsessed with the lives of a woman in Florida.

Today's example of the Republican Culture of Life comes to us from our very own government, which has issued a report stating that:

At least 108 people have died in U.S. custody in the Iraq and Afghanistan wars, and at least 26 have been investigated as criminal homicides involving possible abuse.

The figure, far higher than any previously disclosed, includes cases investigated by the Army, Navy, CIA and Justice Department.

About 65,000 prisoners have been taken during the U.S.-led wars; most have been freed.

The Pentagon has never provided comprehensive information on how many prisoners taken during the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan have died.


Stay tuned for more Republican hypocrisy on "life." I just know there's more where this came from.
Bookmark and Share

Quote of the day
Posted by Jill | 7:01 AM


"What a shame that religion is being used to abuse Terri and her parents instead of comforting all of them and helping them to move forward." -- Scott at Poetic Leanings, 3/21/05
Bookmark and Share

Priorities.....
Posted by Jill | 6:46 AM
Think about it: George W. Bush couldn't cut short his vacation in August 2001 in the face of 52 advisories and a PDB that a terrorist attack was imminent on U.S. soil, but he was more than happy to cut short his vacation in March 2005 to toss some red meat at his base by signing legislation to restor Terri Schiavo's feeding tube.

I guess the 2700 lives that could have been saved in 9/11/01 don't matter only...only the life of one woman in Florida without any cognitive ability.

Not to make light of Terri Schiavo's condition, which is tragic and awful, but that tells me that people without a cerebral cortex are just the kind of base Bush wants.
Bookmark and Share
Sunday, March 20, 2005

How does someone return to normal life after this?
Posted by Jill | 9:52 PM

I shudder to think of the level of mental illness we're going to be dealing with in this country when all the soldiers serving in Iraq come home:

Hi my name is M. D. formaly of A TRP 1-10 CAV 4ID and while in Iraq we had a sport of killing dogs whenever the Iraqis werent shooting us. So when I shot this one at about 50 yards with my M4 and it ran yelping to lower ground, we had to finish it so my friends and I went to it and started shooting it. I ve never seen a dog take as many shots to the head at least 4 as this one did and then after we thought it was dead we dug a hole and when I picked it up with the shovel it came back to life, so we shot it a couple more times....its pretty funny."


(via Digby the Great)
Bookmark and Share

Hypocrisy, Thy Name Is Republican
Posted by Jill | 9:49 PM

Thus Spake Digby (as reprinted all over Blogistan):

By now most people who read liberal blogs are aware that George W. Bush signed a law in Texas that expressly gave hospitals the right to remove life support if the patient could not pay and there was no hope of revival, regardless of the patient's family's wishes. It is called the Texas Futile Care Law. Under this law, a baby was removed from life support against his mother's wishes in Texas just this week. A 68 year old man was given a temporary reprieve by the Texas courts just yesterday.

Those of us who read liberal blogs are also aware that Republicans have voted en masse to pull the plug (no pun intended) on medicaid funding that pays for the kind of care that someone like Terry Schiavo and many others who are not so severely brain damaged need all across this country.

Those of us who read liberal blogs also understand that that the tort reform that is being contemplated by the Republican congress would preclude malpractice claims like that which has paid for Terry Schiavo's care thus far.

Those of us who read liberal blogs are aware that the bankruptcy bill will make it even more difficult for families who suffer a catastrophic illness like Terry Schiavo's because they will not be able to declare chapter 7 bankruptcy and get a fresh start when the gargantuan medical bills become overwhelming.

And those of us who read liberal blogs also know that this grandstanding by the congress is a purely political move designed to appease the religious right and that the legal maneuverings being employed would be anathema to any true small government conservative.

Those who don't read liberal blogs, on the other hand, are seeing a spectacle on television in which the news anchors repeatedly say that the congress is "stepping in to save Terry Schiavo" mimicking the unctuous words of Tom Delay as they grovel and leer at the family and nod sympathetically at the sanctimonious phonies who are using this issue for their political gain.
Bookmark and Share

Wow! Who knew?
Posted by Jill | 1:12 PM

I wonder if Frist and DeLay will still want to keep Terri Schiavo alive once they know about this:




Then who's the guy who's in prison now?

Nice going, CBS News. Why not make yourselves even MORE of a laughingstock?

(via Big Brass Blog)
Bookmark and Share

Jesus toe-tappin' bald-headed Christ in a sidecar...
Posted by Jill | 1:04 PM

The circus gets worse:

Former Green Beret Commander Bo Gritz is trying to conduct a citizen's arrest of Terri Schiavo's husband and the judge who ordered the brain-damaged Florida woman's feeding tube removed so she can be legally starved.

The 66-year-old retired Army Lt. Colonel with his wife, Judy, arrived in Florida from their home in Nevada yesterday with the intent of arresting anyone involved in removing the life-sustaining tube.

Gritz came bearing a notarized "citizen's arrest warrant" addressed to Florida Gov. Jeb Bush and Attorney General Charlie Crist.

His intent is to "paper" state and federal law enforcement offices with his warrant today – one day before Pinellas Circuit Court Judge George Greer's deadline to begin denial of food and water to Terri Schiavo.

Gritz says the "arrest" is designed to allow officials additional options as the Florida governor and legislature maneuver to save the woman from starvation.


I'm gonna put something in writing before the weekend is out. God forbid this ever happens in my family.
Bookmark and Share

Maybe I had it wrong about the ribbon magnets
Posted by Jill | 12:59 PM
I've spilled many finger-taps on those ribbon magnets that have proliferated mostly on SUVs out in my neck of the woods; the ones that tell OTHER drivers, who aren't pumping quite as much cash into the pockets of the Saudis, to "Support Our Troops."

Maybe they aren't talking to other drivers at all. Maybe those ribbons are really a protest, directed to Our President, C-Plus Caligula himself, because of his cynical, cold-hearted policies like those outlined by Pennsylvania Governor Ed Rendell today:


The governor of Pennsylvania on Saturday said the federal government must do a better job helping America's war veterans and criticized proposed budget cuts affecting them.

[snip]

He maintained that budget cuts include "a $350 million reduction in veterans home funding, which wipes out at least 5,000 veterans' nursing home beds."

"If the president's proposed budget cuts are enacted, nearly 60 percent of the 1,600 veterans will lose their daily stipend that allows them to stay in our state's nursing homes, literally forcing them out into the cold."

Vet co-payments for prescription drugs were tripled two years ago, Rendell said, and "now the president is proposing to again double those increased co-pays."

"In the midst of a war, when many new men and women will join the legion of veterans, does it really make sense for the president to increase the cost of vets' prescriptions by 100 percent?"

Rendell criticized a proposal calling for a $250 fee "to be paid by every vet wishing to participate in the Veterans Administration health care program. "

"There may well be some veterans who can afford to do so, but can all vets come up with an extra $250 a year to pay for health care? I doubt it."

He urged "every patriotic American" to contact their legislators and protest budget cuts for veteran services.


Just maybe the ribbon magnets are a protest against the Administraion.

Maybe.

Nah.
Bookmark and Share

Doesn't this violate the "Don't shit where you eat" rule?
Posted by Jill | 9:24 AM

Hoffmania brings us this little tidbit that may give us insight into why Wolfowitz may want the gig as head of the World Bank:

Although many bank insiders and observers predict that the odds strongly favor Wolfowitz eventually getting the job, the furor yesterday indicated that at the very least a fight will rage for several weeks before the board approves him.

Adding fuel to the controversy is concern within the bank staff over Wolfowitz's reported romantic relationship with Shaha Riza, an Arab feminist who works as a communications adviser in the bank's Middle East and North Africa department.

Both divorced, Wolfowitz and Riza have steadfastly declined to talk publicly about their relationship, but they have been regularly spotted at private functions and one source said the two have been dating for about two years. Riza, an Oxford-educated British citizen who was born in Tunisia and grew up in Saudi Arabia, shares Wolfowitz's passion for democratizing the Middle East, according to people who know her.

Bank policy allows spouses and partners to work on the staff as long as neither reports directly to the other, so the Wolfowitz-Riza relationship may not run afoul of those rules. But some staffers, speaking anonymously for fear of offending their prospective boss, said sentiment is running high that the ethics requirements should be stricter in cases involving the chief executive. Through a spokesman, Wolfowitz said in response to a query from The Post: "Needless to say, if a personal relationship presents a potential conflict of interest, I will comply with bank policies to resolve the issue."


Now, the idea of an ardent Jewish Zionist who works for one of the most anti-feminist presidents in history "dating" an Arab feminist is pretty interesting; right up there with James Carville and Mary Matalin, only with hints of Montague/Capulet blood feuds added for spice.

However, the tin ear that this Administration continues to show in affiars that smack at all of conflict of interest wouldn't be tolerated in anyone else, particularly someone with a "D" after their name. Once again, the IOKIYAR rule is in full flower.
Bookmark and Share

Question for conservatives
Posted by Jill | 9:08 AM

Can some conservative who supports the Bush Administration and Republicans in Congress please tell me how getting involved in a private industry's affairs (baseball) and in passing legislation designed for one specific individual is consitent with "conservatism" and "less government interference"?
Bookmark and Share

Batten down the hatches, folks
Posted by Jill | 8:12 AM

Bush's approval ratings are dropping like a stone. He's down to the same pathetic 45% mark that he was when 9/11 occurred just a day after a big story broke in Newsweek about how Republican chicanery resulted in the 2000 election result.

Remember those early days of the Bush Administration? Hell, by September 1, there was talk that this Administration was over already. Sometimes having the World Trade Center collapse and the Pentagon be hit by low-flying aircraft on your watch can be a great career move.

Newsweek online reports Bush's dismal showing:



  • Forty-five percent of all Americans approve of the way he is doing his job, a five-point dip from early February; 48 percent disapprove, up six points.

  • Only one-third of all Americans (33 percent) approve of his proposal to create investment accounts under Social Security, the poll found, while 59 percent disapprove

  • His approval ratings are negative on the federal budget deficit (29 percent approve, 60 percent disapprove), health care (34 percent to 56 percent), the economy (42 percent to 51 percent) and the situation in Iraq (41 percent versus 54 percent). And on the heels of a Senate vote to pave the way for drilling in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge, the president’s rating on the environment is also at a low point (41 percent approve, 45 percent disapprove).




The only bright spot is national security, where Bush still enjoys a 57-35 edge.

This can only mean one thing: Either another attack is going to happen, or we're going to hear talk of "chatter" and "plans" any day now. Gotta keep those people afraid, now!
Bookmark and Share

George W. Bush Let Sun Hudson Die
Posted by Jill | 8:00 AM

Let me just reiterate, for those who didn't read my post about Terri Schiavo: A Texas law allows doctors to remove life support from if the hospital ethics committee agrees, and after a 10-day period in which the family may seek another facility.

The ugly underbelly of this was revealed days before life support was removed from Sun Hudson, when the Chief Medical Officer at St. Luke's Episcopal Hospital in Houston said that a patient's inability to pay for medical care combined with a prognosis that renders further care futile are two reasons a hospital might suggest cutting off life support.

The latter I don't have a problem with, but the former is downright horrifying -- and another reason why the health care system MUST be revamped in this country.

Atrios, from whence this story comes, notes that it was George W. Bush who signed the bill which put this law into effect. Yes, that George W. Bush, the one who touts himself as always being on the side of human life. But this decision is consistent with Bush's worldview on life in general. Fetal life is always important. Iraqi life is NEVER important. And the lives of everyone else depend on their ability to pay.
Bookmark and Share