"Only dull people are brilliant at breakfast"
-Oscar Wilde
Brilliant at Breakfast title banner "The liberal soul shall be made fat, and he that watereth, shall be watered also himself."
-- Proverbs 11:25
"...you have a choice: be a fighting liberal or sit quietly. I know what I am, what are you?" -- Steve Gilliard, 1964 - 2007

"For straight up monster-stomping goodness, nothing makes smoke shoot out my ears like Brilliant@Breakfast" -- Tata

"...the best bleacher bum since Pete Axthelm" -- Randy K.

"I came here to chew bubblegum and kick ass. And I'm all out of bubblegum." -- "Rowdy" Roddy Piper (1954-2015), They Live
Tuesday, June 08, 2010

Redoubting Thomas

(By American Zen's Mike Flannigan, on loan from Ari)

The condemnation of Helen Thomas for her statements last month on the Israelis is, or should be, a referendum on the longstanding state of foreign affairs between the United States and Israel. The state of affairs hasn't changed one iota since Israel became a state in 1948: Turning a blind eye to Israel's war crimes and terrorist acts, even when US servicemen are slaughtered by the dozens, covering up said war crimes and terrorist acts and even generously giving Israel $3 billion annually to subsidize said war crimes and terrorist acts.

That's why it's savagely amusing to see the rank hypocrisy on the part of the American press establishment and watching them break their pencil necks fleeing from Helen Thomas, the redoubtable doyenne of White House correspondents, as if she had a suicide vest strapped to her torso. Her speaker bureau dropped her as a client. The reliably craven nonentity Craig Crawford abandoned a project with her. Robert Gibbs has publicly condemned her while admitting that he wasn't speaking for the President. And Hearst Syndicate obviously showed barely enough patience with Thomas to offer just enough time for her to make a hasty exit with no fanfare.

What Olympic-class hypocrites.

If Thomas's line of questioning sounded more like political science debates and heckling instead of legitimate questions from a respected syndicated columnist, it should have been taken as a referendum in itself of her growing frustration over not getting answers from an endless parade of press secretaries ranging from Pierre Salinger and Bill Moyer to Tony Snow and Robert Gibbs. Being of Arab descent, Thomas was also understandably frustrated by America's inexplicable turn the other cheek policy regarding Israel.

If Thomas' challenges to the power elite to provide explanations for invasions, occupations and wanton murder sounded pro-Arab, then perhaps, instead of nailing her upon the cross, we ought to examine why, although the answer is obvious: Since 9/11, Arabs and Muslims have suffered infinitely more than Jews. Neither the Jews nor the Israelis need our or anyone's pity and whatever pity they'd earned since the Holocaust has long since worn thin.

The hypocrisy comes in when one remembers even in the abstract the Obama White House's infinite tolerance and even deference toward the nation's most unhinged right wing lunatics who called Senator then President Obama a terrorist sympathizer, a Muslim, a fascist, a Socialist, a Communist, an illegal alien and openly wished for him (and America) to fail.

Helen Thomas wasn't attacking the administration or the character of the President or attacking members of the First Family. Helen Thomas was merely saying in an unguarded moment what many true liberals were thinking but didn't have the chutzpah to say out loud: That the Israelis (not the Jews) ought to get out of Palestine, the Northern Ireland of the Middle East.

It was a classic Gotcha moment recorded for loving posterity by a group of pro-Israel amateurs now reveling in their 15 minutes of fame (Note to Live Rabbi: The coast is clear in Eastern Europe, the home of millions of Jews. The concentration camps, gas chambers and ovens have long since stopped operating.).

Helen Thomas never accused anyone of being a terrorist simply for showing concern for the mass slaughter of innocent Arabs. She also never grossly misquoted anyone.

Helen Thomas never wished for the President to fail.

Helen Thomas never broke her own personal rule to never go after the President's children.

Helen Thomas never beat the war drums for any administration
and spreading rumors about fictional WMD's.

Helen Thomas never outed a covert CIA agent with impunity.

I could go after every right wing lunatic and pro-Israel apologist for much more despicable remarks that were made with complete impunity, remarks that stood unchallenged by the Obama White House and the ten other administrations covered by Helen Thomas in her half century of covering our nation's seat of power. But time forbids.

The redoubtable Thomas, once a person who commanded respect from all until Obama's brain-damaged predecessor held his last presser, is now herself behind a redoubt of another sort. She's now replaced Jim Joyce, Tony Hayward and Lloyd Blankfein as the most hated person in America for simply speaking the truth: That the Israelis ought to leave Palestine and stop using Hamas as an excuse for committing war crimes and starving the Palestinians to death in their slow-motion genocide. The woman who provided America with countless Gotcha moments has now been toppled from her hard-won perch with a single Gotcha moment from a group of pro-Israeli amateurs.

And there's something very, very disturbing and infuriating about that.
Bookmark and Share
Blogger molly said...
thank you for the truth. I applaud Helen Thomas for speaking truth to power.

"Get out of Palestine"

And go where, perchance?

Back to the Arab countries which used the creation of Israel as an excuse to throw out their own Jews?

Back to the European nations who were perfectly happy to see their Jews leave (and which killed a few thousand Holocaust survivors so that they would indeed get the message that it was time to go)?

To the US, which closed its doors to Jews in the 1930s and 1940s?

Where do you propose the Jews of Israel go?

Anonymous mandt said...
What bullshit! You go Helen. It's time to give Israel a big time kick in the ass!

Blogger The One True Tami said...
The Holocaust has long since worn thin? I don't condemn the oppression and extermination of anyone, but I can't get past that line. I wanted to, but no, no, I can't do it.

Anonymous dmg said...
interesting. i'm as liberal as the next guy, provided the next guy isn't, oh, william kunstler. and neither i nor any other liberal i know has said that israel needs to get out of palestine. according to you, that means i'm not a true liberal.

Blogger Tonio Kruger said...
Seems to me there has been way too many Americans as of late telling other people to go back where they came from. I certainly never expected to hear that sentiment applauded on this site.

Blogger Interrobang said...
An Israeli friend of mine has Israeli-born parents. That makes him as Israeli as I am Canadian, and if we're going to start cancelling countries by fiat because they were created by British colonialism, a lot of us had better start packing.

I mean, if I'm not Canadian just like he's not Israeli, where do I go back to? My adoptive family's ancestry traces back to Scotland, England, the United States, and Holland, and my biological ancestry traces back to England, France, and the Ukraine.

But it's only not okay for people to live in countries they stole from the natives with the help of the British Empire when those people are Jews, I guess.

Anonymous mandt said...
"telling other people to go back where they came from"----especially when it was/is hell. The Jewish people(s) is one powerful 'just' narrative; the apartheid state of Israel, quite another.

Anonymous Blue Girl said...
The whole fiasco was surreal. What I noticed was the dearth of "journalists" who stood up for the First Amendment and the right to free speech. When people on the right say stupid things, they have free speech rights and the librul left is trying to censor them, dontcha know.

My grandmother had a saying for people like that..."Worthless as tits on a man."