"Only dull people are brilliant at breakfast" -Oscar Wilde |
"The liberal soul shall be made fat, and he that watereth, shall be watered also himself." -- Proverbs 11:25 |
Screen Actors Guild National President Alan Rosenberg on Thursday called fining actors for indecency on TV "incomprehensible." The SAG chief made the remark in his testimony before the U.S. Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation, which is currently considering legislation that would raise FCC fines for indecency.
Under the new legislation, which has already been approved by the House, the FCC could fine individuals up to $500,000 for speech or actions deemed indecent.
"SAG members work primarily on scripted projects – we are hired to perform a role. To be threatened with half a million dollars in fines for doing our jobs is incomprehensible," he said during the committee’s Jan. 19 hearing on decency in Washington D.C.
Unlike broadcast licensees, individual citizens, including the members I represent here today, are not aware of the FCC’s vague and changing indecency standards. Should they really be subject to half million dollar fines without a warning?," he asked.
Rosenberg also spoke out against censoring programming to make it suitable for children. He cited CBS’s 'CSI: Crime Scene Investigation', on which his wife Marg Helgenberger stars, as an example of programming that is not appropriate for children, but should be available for adults to watch.
"If all of America’s entertainment output were to be distilled to a level that is appropriate for children, every movie and program would be rated G," he continued. "If you allow the content considerations of a single demographic (be it children or some narrow segment of an adult special interest group) to dictate the standards for what is appropriate for the entire nation, you suppress one of this country’s greatest assets – the diversity and creativity of the American people."
He pointed out that many safeguards already exist to protect children from inappropriate content, such as the V-chip, the TV ratings system, and the cable industry’s new family-tier of channels.
Tom Carpenter, AFTRA's general counsel and legislative-affairs director, and noted actor Joe Pantoliano, co-president of the Creative Coalition, previously decried the proposed legislation before the committee on Nov. 30.
As of press time, legislation remains in committee.
A full transcript of Rosenberg’s statement can be found on SAG’s website: www.sag.org.