"Only dull people are brilliant at breakfast"
-Oscar Wilde
Brilliant at Breakfast title banner "The liberal soul shall be made fat, and he that watereth, shall be watered also himself."
-- Proverbs 11:25
"...you have a choice: be a fighting liberal or sit quietly. I know what I am, what are you?" -- Steve Gilliard, 1964 - 2007

"For straight up monster-stomping goodness, nothing makes smoke shoot out my ears like Brilliant@Breakfast" -- Tata

"...the best bleacher bum since Pete Axthelm" -- Randy K.

"I came here to chew bubblegum and kick ass. And I'm all out of bubblegum." -- "Rowdy" Roddy Piper (1954-2015), They Live
Monday, June 30, 2008

John asks the question so I don't have to
Posted by Jill | 6:09 AM
The word "entitled" has been thrown around a lot this primary season. Barack Obama's supporters perceive Hillary Clinton as feeling she's entitled to the presidency. Hillary Clinton's supporters find Barack Obama "arrogant" and think HE feels entitled to the presidency.

But is there a candidate with a bigger sense of entitlement than John McCain? In media circles, the mere mention of McCain must be accompanied by "war hero." But is he? Does even five years in a Hanoi prison, succumbing to torture and making a propaganda video for one's enemy captors, however understandable, make you a hero? Or are you just a victim, one deserving of understanding and empathy -- but not the presidency?

Or is this one of those things no one dares talk about, like the guys in the World Trade Center who were sitting at their desks having their morning coffee when a plane hit their building and immolated them, or the ones stranded on the high floors or the ones who tried to get out and just didn't make it? I know that the family of one of these guys has comforted themselves for the past seven years with the idea that their son/brother died a hero. But that isn't the case for the guys who were just unlucky enough to show up for work in the financial and real estate and other firms headquartered in the building that day.

Some of these people ARE heroes. Abraham Zelmanowitz is a hero. He stayed behind rather than leave a quadriplegic friend to die alone. Brian Clark is a hero. He rescued Stanley Praimnath, a man who literally had an airplane fly into his office, simply by talking him through breaking through the wall that divided him from safety, then helped pull him through. There are no doubt many, ,many other, less celebrated stories of heroism that day from people who weren't those who were heroic by definition -- the firefighters and police who tried to get people out. But not everyone who died that day is by definition a hero.

There's no shame in being the victim of a horrific tragedy, or even of capture by the enemy while in war. I know that here in the U.S., we fancy ourselves to be lantern-jawed superheroes, and we want to believe that heroism exists in all events of adversity. The loss of a kid who was sitting in the back seat of a car when a classmate skidded on a rain-slicked road and hit a tree doesn't have to have heroically tried to get the others out of the car in order for his death to be a tragedy. A guy having his morning coffee and bagel when a plane hits his building does't have to try to get other people out for his death to be a tragedy. Why should we add the burden of trying to find heroism in the sudden death of a loved one to the shock and grief experienced by those s/he left behind? Why should we feel we have to turn everyone who is lost senselessly into Spider-Man in order to mourn them? A loss is a loss, whether the person was heroic in his/her last moments or not.

And we don't have to elevate the misfortune of enemy capture, and even the admirable feat of mere survival of an enemy prison, into a free pass to the presidency.

John Aravosis asks the question I've long wanted to but didn't dare: How does being captured by the enemy make you a military expert? In theory, McCain's experience should make him MORE reticent to go to war, and to stay at war, without a clearly-defined mission. And yet he favors endless occupation of Iraq. He more than anyone else in politics today understands what torture does to a man -- and yet he caved to the sadist George W. Bush on torture, obviously for purely political reasons.

John McCain can say "Country first" till the cows come home. It doesn't change the fact that this is a man who not only plays the torture card the way Hillary Clinton played the "The boys are being mean to me card", but who thinks that being captured and tortured by the enemy somehow makes you an expert on All Things Military.

There are few things more dangerous to long-term psychological health than the notion that because you endured something horrific, it means you're entitled to something. This country is full of people who have had years of therapy and gotten stuck at "It's because my father/mother never loved me and so the world owes me a living", rather than taking the next step into healing.

The only thing that should entitle John McCain to the presidency is whether he would be the best leader for the country. And in his craven capitulation to the worst elements of his party and his compromising of the very long-held positions that have led to the relentless hammering by the media of the "maverick" meme, the answer is "no." And it doesn't matter what happened to him in that Hanoi prison.

UPDATE: Wesley Clark doesn't think that getting shot down is a qualification for the presidency either:


Bookmark and Share
Anonymous Anonymous said...
How does being captured by the enemy make you a military expert?

How does spending one's time as a "community organizer" and as a back-bencher in the Illinois state senate make that person a military expert?

Remember, the post by Aravosis had to do with what Gen. Wesley Clark said, and Clark, being a former general, would seem to have many more years of experience than McCain. But, Clark is not running for President. The guy he supports, the "community organizer" and Illinois state senate back-bencher, is. And Obama's experience on military matters is a big, fat zero.

Anonymous Anonymous said...
Since the Swiftboaters made the untouchable questions alright to ask. I have three which I would like answered by John McCain.
1. You attempted suicide twice while being held captive. Do you think the stress of the Oval Office might cause these problems to be re-occur?
2. Are you or have you taken psychotropics for PTSD, or other neurological problems not previously released? will you release your prescription documentation from the Vietnam era?
3. While you were being tortured did you give up any information that could be used as blackmail against you as a sitting U.S. President?

Anonymous Anonymous said...
oh, hold on "anonymous", isn't exactly that `Swift-Boating' is a grave political crime?

Blogger D. said...
Somewhere in memory (found it!) lurk the lyrics to Tom Paxton's The Iron Man, which may or may not be relevant.

It's not as though military expertise is a prerequisite, any more than a surname of two syllables or fewer is. And Clark's expertise can be called on. McCain...has he held command? Because, y'know, I keep hearing about his temper...

Anonymous Anonymous said...
Those who would have collaborated for free criticizing what someone did under torture - strangely without mentioning "war crimes"? What has the enemy sympathizer community come to?

Anonymous Anonymous said...
Wesley Clark, super genius.

He's going a great job of getting Republicans and others who really don't like McCain all that much to get a chance to really embrace him over an experience for which Obama has no equal.

I'll assume that Wes Clark will be relegated to one of those low level staff positions from which all the Obama gaffes seem to emanate.

Anonymous Anonymous said...
You've shown your foolishness in trying to belittle community organizing - I know this may be difficult for you to comprehend but bringing people together to better their community is actually a good thing. I know, crazy, huh? No one is disputing McCain's military service - just his
honesty, emotional retardation, and overall sanity. That said, I'm not at all surprised that you support his election to office.