"Only dull people are brilliant at breakfast" -Oscar Wilde |
"The liberal soul shall be made fat, and he that watereth, shall be watered also himself." -- Proverbs 11:25 |
As a 13-year-old Palm Beach County girl prepared this week to end a pregnancy she says she does not want, the Florida Department of Children and Families went to court to stop her from having the abortion.
The American Civil Liberties Union challenged the state's position Wednesday, saying DCF is overstepping its authority and violating the girl's constitutional rights.
The girl, identified only as L.G., lives in a shelter for abused and neglected teens and found out two weeks ago during a doctor's appointment that she is pregnant. Soon after, she told her DCF caseworker in Palm Beach County that she wanted an abortion.
The caseworker scheduled an appointment for the girl to have an abortion Tuesday and planned to drive her to the office, according to an appeal filed by the ACLU. On the same day, lawyers for DCF filed an emergency motion to stop L.G. from terminating her pregnancy.
In a hearing that day before Juvenile Court Judge Ronald Alvarez, the state argued that Florida law gives DCF authority to prevent L.G. from having an abortion. The state said the girl was not able to make an informed decision because of her age and immaturity, according to the appeal filed Wednesday by the ACLU.
Alvarez agreed to delay the abortion until the court could give L.G. a psychological evaluation to find out whether an abortion could cause her emotional harm. The judge also wanted the court to determine whether the girl would face medical risks in terminating the pregnancy or carrying the baby to term.
The ACLU and the Legal Aid Society appealed that decision Wednesday to the 4th District Court of Appeal, saying neither DCF nor the court had any right to interfere.
The U.S. Supreme Court's position that women have the right to choose an abortion overrides any state argument or law, ACLU of Florida Executive Director Howard Simon said.
"Whatever politically motivated, convoluted legal rationale they (DCF leaders) can come up with, they cannot ignore the constitutional rights of women as recognized by the U.S. Supreme Court," Simon said.
DCF spokeswoman Marilyn Munoz said Wednesday that DCF is "acting in the best interest of the child." She cited a Florida state law that says DCF cannot permit an abortion without a judge's consent, but declined further comment.
A spokesman for Gov. Jeb Bush also declined comment.
Under Florida law, a 13-year-old can have an abortion without her parents knowing or agreeing. The legislature is considering a bill this session that would require parental notification, but not consent, for girls under the age of 16.
"Unwed pregnant minor or minor mother; consent to medical services for
minor or minor's child valid.--
"(1) An unwed pregnant minor may consent to the performance of
medical or surgical care or services relating to her pregnancy by a
hospital or clinic or by a physician licensed under chapter 458 or
chapter 459, and such consent is valid and binding as if she had
achieved her majority.
"(2) An unwed minor mother may consent to the performance of medical
or surgical care or services for her child by a hospital or clinic or
by a physician licensed under chapter 458 or chapter 459, and such
consent is valid and binding as if she had achieved her majority.
"(3) Nothing in this act shall affect the provisions of s. 390.0111."